• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Peter Pan Diner - Classic American Dining with Outstanding Food and Service in Bay Shore, NY

Peter Pan Diner, nestled in Bay Shore, NY, is a cherished local gem known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and spotless interiors. For over 30 years, it has delighted diners with perfectly cooked classics like juicy burgers with sautéed onions, crispy onion rings, and fresh, vibrant sides. The service shines as much as the food, with friendly staff making every meal memorable. Desserts like Lemon Meringue and Chocolate Cream pie leave guests raving. Whether it’s a turkey club panini or a veggie burger, Peter Pan Diner consistently delivers satisfying, lip-smacking meals that feel like home with every visit.

Peter Pan Diner at a glance

  • Address 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
  • Phone +1 631-665-1788
  • Restaurant type Diner , American restaurant , Breakfast restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Peter Pan Diner: Reviews & Ratings

Ronald Thomas All Rights Reserved (ALL RIGHTS RESERVED)
4

Great food! Great service! Great experience everytime! Have been coming here for at least 30 years!

Fabby momz
4

Food was really delicious. Service was great ! Nice inviting atmosphere. Love the birthday celebration style. Overall was a nice place to sit and enjoy my meal .

Michael T Calvaruso
5

Petter Pan Diner was a much more than pleasant surprise. First off that they were open for inside dining was great. Next, the interior was immaculate the decor warm & welcoming & the staff very friendly & top of their game in serving. Now the food? Oh man the food! Both my wife & I had burger deluxe platters. I got mine with sauteed onions added to the burger...YUM. Everything was cooked to perfection, the burger just right aaaand juicy. The sweet potato fries, the onion rings crispy on the outside & delicious on the inside! Even the Cole Slaw & pickle were super fresh & delicious. My wife ordered a slice of Lemon Meringue & I ordered the Chocolate Cream pie. We both were over the moon how fantastic these.two desserts were! When we left we were both thoroughly full & very happy! This diner really delivered two completely wonderful, lip smacking good meals. Go visit them!

Frank M
5

Had a very pleasant experience. Great dinner food. Had the turkey club panini and the veggie burger. I'd recommend both. The turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.

Rick White
5

Excellent Diner, Delicious food and Spectacular service. Highly recommend!! Roxy is one of their best waitresses.

Gail Melisa
5

One of the best diners on the Island. I have been dining here for over 15 years. There are lots of regular customers. Favorites: Belgian waffle with fruit salad, matzoh ball soup, turkey bacon Runners up: chicken noodle soup, omelettes Staff is friendly and professional. Highly recommend

Lorraine T
5

The best diner! Clean, efficient, friendly. Has everything you'd expect and more from a diner. Corned beef hash at breakfast was perfect and not greasy at all. Food well prepared and presented. Our server, sorry, I didn't get her name, but she was excellent. The manager was friendly and professional, and dressed in a crisp tailored shirt. There were two birthdays and they were prepared with a recorded song that everyone sang to. I would definitely recommend this place.

Annie Pham
5

It's one of my favorite restaurants on the island! Great food, reasonable pricing for the amount you get! 10/10

Location

  • Peter Pan Diner
    Peter Pan Diner
    999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States Hotline: +1 631-665-1788

Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore, NY, stands as a cherished spot where tradition meets quality in every bite. With a legacy spanning over three decades, this breakfast and diner haven captures the essence of comforting American cuisine paired with warm, attentive service.

Stepping inside, you are greeted by an inviting atmosphere that feels both nostalgic and fresh. The interior is immaculate, with decor that exudes a welcoming charm, making it the perfect place to unwind and enjoy a meal. The staff’s friendliness and professionalism elevate the dining experience, ensuring you feel valued from start to finish.

The food truly shines here. Their burger deluxe platter, with juicy, perfectly cooked patties and crispy sides like sweet potato fries and golden onion rings, stands out as a highlight. Freshness is key, evident in the crisp coleslaw and pickle accompaniments that balance the meal beautifully. The turkey club panini offers a creative twist on a classic, showcasing the diner’s ability to innovate without sacrificing comfort.

Dessert at Peter Pan Diner is not to be missed. The Lemon Meringue slice bursts with tangy sweetness, while the Chocolate Cream pie provides a rich, indulgent finish. These treats reflect the diner’s commitment to quality and leave a lasting impression on the palate.

What makes Peter Pan Diner truly special is the consistent excellence — great food, superb service, and a warm ambiance that customers return to time and again. This is a place where every visit feels like coming home, and every dish tells a story of care and craftsmanship.

If you find yourself in Bay Shore, dialing +1 631-665-1788 or stopping by 999 Sunrise Hwy should be on your list. Whether it’s a casual meal or a celebration, Peter Pan Diner promises a satisfying, memorable experience.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards